Showing 1–120 of 165 results
-
Ribbon Candy
$4.25 +View Product -
Art Candy
$4.25 +View Product -
Sparkling Holiday Classics Mix – AKA Victory Mix!
$4.25 +View Product -
Small Penny Candy Store in a Box
$14.97 +View Product -
Appalachian Handmade Potato Candy
$10.25 +View Product -
Yesterday’s Medicine Sampler
$21.00 +View Product -
Take-A-Break Gummy Bears
$2.48 +View Product -
3 Tier Retro Fun Gift Set with Congrats Card
$52.00 +View Product -
Marshmallow Snow Cones
$3.75 +View Product -
Retro Candy Mish-Mash of retro surprises in decorative 8-ounce bag, Old Time Fun
$6.25 +View Product -
Car Ride Box
$25.00 +View Product -
Gummy Bears
$3.89 +View Product -
Retro Candy Bar Classics
$9.75 +View Product -
Fabulous Fandango Box
$21.00 +View Product -
Ice Blue Mints
$4.25 +View Product -
Retro Angel Mints
$4.76 +View Product -
1900s Retro Timeline Box
$21.00 +View Product -
Toys and Treats Box
$14.97 +View Product -
Pop-A-Lot Lollipop Collection Box
$8.97 +View Product -
Large Penny Candy Store in a Box
$34.00 +View Product -
Licorice Lovers Box
$21.00 +View Product -
Fabulous Fandango- All Retro, All Fun!
$8.97 +View Product -
Gummy Candy Timeline
$21.00 +View Product -
Office Candy Collection
$17.75 +View Product -
Fabulous Jewelry Box With Candy Jewels & Gems
$12.50 +View Product -
Black Licorice Laces
$4.76 +View Product -
Boston Baked Beans
$5.88 +View Product -
Princess Purse
$11.97 +View Product -
Taffy Treasures: A Mix of Taffy Favorites through Time
$5.89 +View Product -
Classic Candy Corn
$3.89 +View Product -
Large Jawbreaker
$5.01 +View Product -
My Grandmother’s Purse Hard Candy
$5.25 +View Product -
Black Licorice Wheels
$3.89 +View Product -
Mint Malted Milk Balls
$3.89 +View Product -
Moon Pie
$1.40 +View Product -
Sour Tangerine Drops
$4.47 +View Product -
Handmade Cherry Stain Glass Candy
$5.97 +View Product -
All-American Caramels
$7.27 +View Product -
Anise Squares Hard Candy
$3.89 +View Product -
Astro Pops
$4.25 +View Product -
Retro Candy Cigarettes
$1.36 +View Product -
BBQ Peanuts
$5.88 +View Product -
Spicy Retro Clove Balls
$3.89 +View Product -
Beemans Gum
$1.09 +View Product -
Bit-O-Honey Toffee
$3.89 +View Product -
Black Jack Gum
$1.09 +View Product -
Bubblegum Cigarettes with “smoke”
$2.48 +View Product -
Retro Bubblegum Balls
$5.25 +View Product -
Bubblegum Cigar
$1.36 +View Product -
Buttermints
$3.89 +View Product -
Grandma’s Retro Butterscotch Disks
$3.89 +View Product -
Canada Mints
$5.88 +View Product -
Goetze’s Caramel Creams
$4.76 +View Product -
Retro Caramel Cubes
$4.76 +View Product -
Caramel Gift Box
$14.97 +View Product -
Caramel Gift Box – Thank You
$14.97 +View Product -
Milk Duds
$2.21 +View Product -
Modjeska – Caramel Marshmallow
$7.27 +View Product -
Retro Sweetheart Candies
$3.89 +View Product -
Chocolate Cigarettes
$3.25 +View Product -
Chocolate Covered Coconut Squares
$12.97 +View Product -
Chocolate Covered Devil Dogs
$5.88 +View Product -
Chocolate Covered Peanuts
$4.25 +View Product -
Chocolate Covered Sponge Candy
$8.37 +View Product -
Dark Chocolate Covered Strawberries
$12.25 +View Product -
Chocolate Covered Retro Twinkies
$5.88 +View Product -
Chocolate Covered Wintergreen Patties
$12.97 +View Product -
Chocolate Filled Straws
$5.25 +View Product -
Chocolate Nonpareils
$4.25 +View Product -
Chocolate Caramel Pecan Turtles
$5.88 +View Product -
Cherry Mash
$2.21 +View Product -
Choward’s Fragrant Violet Gum
$2.48 +View Product -
Choward’s Fragrant Violet Mints
$2.48 +View Product -
Chuckles
$2.21 +View Product -
Chunky with Satisfying Nuts and Raisins
$2.21 +View Product -
Cinnamon Drops – Individually Wrapped
$3.89 +View Product -
Circus Peanuts
$3.89 +View Product -
Clark Bar
$2.21 +View Product -
Andes Snap Bars
$2.21 +View Product -
Classic Sour Balls
$3.89 +View Product -
Clove Gum
$1.09 +View Product -
Bourbon Flavored Chocolate Cordials
$11.47 +View Product -
Irish Cream Chocolate Cordials
$11.47 +View Product -
Rum Flavored Chocolate Cordials
$11.47 +View Product -
Colorful Rock Candy on a Stick
$1.40 +View Product -
Cotton Candy
$3.97 +View Product -
Cracker Jacks
$1.25 +View Product -
Dots Theater Box
$1.65 +View Product -
Dubble Bubble Big Bar
$2.48 +View Product -
Dutch Salt Licorice
$4.76 +View Product -
Festive Fruit Flavored Jelly Slices
$3.89 +View Product -
Retro Fireballs
$3.89 +View Product -
Saltwater Taffy
$5.89 +View Product -
Ginger Drops
$4.47 +View Product -
Gold Mine Gum
$2.21 +View Product -
Goo Goo Clusters – A Classic Since 1912
$2.21 +View Product -
Good N’ Plenty Licorice
$3.89 +View Product -
Grandma’s Favorite Cinnamon Disks
$3.89 +View Product -
Gummy Cola Bottles
$3.89 +View Product -
Retro Gummy Eggs – Better Than Bacon!
$3.89 +View Product -
Gummy Valentine’s Hearts
$3.89 +View Product -
Gummy Sharks
$3.89 +View Product -
Gummy Worms
$3.89 +View Product -
Traditional 1800s Jelly Beans
$3.89 +View Product -
Jelly Belly Beans – Assorted
$4.97 +View Product -
Handmade Chocolate Cherry Cups
$8.15 +View Product -
Handmade Chocolate Four-Flavor Stack
$9.45 +View Product -
Handmade Molasses Pulls
$4.76 +View Product -
Handmade Original Buttercrunch
$8.37 +View Product -
Hard Candy Starlight Mints
$3.89 +View Product -
Heath Milk Chocolate English Toffee Candy Bar
$2.21 +View Product -
Retro Jawbreakers AKA Jaw Busters
$3.89 +View Product -
Jolly Ranchers
$3.89 +View Product -
JuJu Coins
$3.89 +View Product -
Junior Mints Theater Box
$2.21 +View Product -
Licorice Allsorts
$3.89 +View Product -
Licorice Bridge Mix with Pastels
$4.76 +View Product -
Red Licorice Laces
$4.76 +View Product -
Black Licorice Pipes
$1.21 +View Product -
LifeSavers – Pack of Three
$4.25 +View Product