Showing 121–151 of 151 results
-
Peppermint Puffs – Refreshing and Cool. Perfect for Grandmothers, dinners, & holidays.
$3.89 +View Product -
Pixy Stix, Retro Fizz – A Classic Favorite!
$2.21 +View Product -
Pop Rocks – Retro Fun!
$1.36 +View Product -
Popcorn Balls – A fun food all year long dating back to the 1800s. Enjoy the old-fashioned way – w/ lemonade
$2.97 +View Product -
Red & White Jelly Hearts
$4.25 +View Product -
Cinnamon Red Hot Imperials
$3.89 +View Product -
Reed’s Iconic Candies – Three Flavors – Childhood memories in a roll since 1893. They’re BACK!
$2.21 +View Product -
Ribbon Candy
$4.25 +View Product -
Rock Candy on a String, Multi-Purpose Tradition – Used as a medicine, fermenting agent, and drink ingredient
$5.00 +View Product -
Root Beer Barrels – Prohibitionists Beware
$3.89 +View Product -
Sack O’ Coins
$3.89 +View Product -
Satellite Wafer (Flying Saucers)
$3.89 +View Product -
Skybar
$2.21 +View Product -
Soft Licorice Drops
$4.76 +View Product -
Sparkling Holiday Classics Mix – AKA Victory Mix! The perfect variety of Christmas nostalgia
$4.25 +View Product -
Dutch Chalk Licorice – Mid-1800s – enjoyed as candy. Classic black licorice covered in hard sugary candy coating
$4.76 +View Product -
Strawberry-Filled Candy – A Gift of Love
$5.47 +View Product -
Sugar Babies
$1.75 +View Product -
Sugar Daddy Candy -1930s Caramel Pops
$1.75 +View Product -
Swedish Fish
$3.89 +View Product -
SweeTart Candy
$1.21 +View Product -
Teaberry Gum
$1.09 +View Product -
Tootsie Roll Big Bar – Early 1900s. Was named after the inventor’s daughter Clara, whose nickname was “Tootsie”
$2.75 +View Product -
Hot Tamales
$3.89 +View Product -
Traditional Multicolored Gum Drops – Circa 1805. From the Turkish Delight, sent to Civil War & World War soldiers
$3.89 +View Product -
Truly Tart- Regal Crown Candy
$2.21 +View Product -
Turkish Taffy – Smack It, Crack It!
$1.49 +View Product -
Wax Lips
$1.96 +View Product -
Yesterday’s Medicine
$10.47 +View Product -
Zagnut
$2.21 +View Product -
ZotZ
$3.89 +View Product