True TreatsRetro & Penny Candy
Showing 25–48 of 130 results
-
Chocolate Covered Caramels with Salt
$9.97 Buy & Explore -
Chocolate Covered Coconut Squares
$12.97 Buy & Explore -
Chocolate Covered Peanuts – Fun Favorite
$3.47 Buy & Explore -
Chocolate Covered Wintergreen Patties
$12.97 Buy & Explore -
Chocolate Filled Straws
$4.25 Buy & Explore -
Chocolate Nonpareils with White Sprinkles
$3.47 Buy & Explore -
Chopped Cherries Cherry Mash
$2.21 Buy & Explore -
Choward’s Fragrant Violet Gum
$2.21 Buy & Explore -
Choward’s Fragrant Violet Mints
$2.21 Buy & Explore -
Chuckles, Retro Jelly from 1931
$2.21 Buy & Explore -
Chunky with Satisfying Nuts and Raisins
$1.29 Buy & Explore -
Circus Peanuts: The True Circus Candy
$3.25 Buy & Explore -
Clark Bar – Now a Cup!
$1.21 Buy & Explore -
Classic Andes Snap Bar – Three Full-Size Bars
$3.75 Buy & Explore -
Classic Jelly Beans – Plump, Soft, Traditional
$3.47 Buy & Explore -
Classic Sour Balls – Individually Wrapped
$3.47 Buy & Explore -
Clear Toy (Barley Candy)
$3.47 Buy & Explore -
Clove Flavored Chewing Gum
$0.97 Buy & Explore -
Dots -Three Boxes of Chewy Treats
$3.75 Buy & Explore -
Dubble Bubble Big Bar – First Bubblegum in U.S.A.
$2.21 Buy & Explore -
Dutch Salt Licorice for Salt Lovers
$4.25 Buy & Explore -
Fabulous Fandango- All Retro, All Fun!
$8.97 Buy & Explore -
Fabulous Jewelry Box with Jewels & Gems
$12.50 Buy & Explore -
Festive Fruit Flavored Jelly Slices
$3.47 Buy & Explore