Showing 121–199 of 199 results
-
Fruit Stripe Gum- with Tattoos
$1.52 +View Product -
George Washington Carver Peanut Brittle
$9.25 +View Product -
Gold Mine Gum
$2.21 +View Product -
Goo Goo Clusters – A Classic Since 1912
$2.21 +View Product -
Grandma’s Favorite Cinnamon Disks
$3.89 +View Product -
Gummy Cola Bottles
$3.89 +View Product -
Retro Gummy Eggs – Better Than Bacon!
$3.89 +View Product -
Gummy Valentine’s Hearts
$3.89 +View Product -
Gummy Sharks
$3.89 +View Product -
Gummy Worms
$3.89 +View Product -
Traditional 1800s Jelly Beans
$3.89 +View Product -
Jelly Belly Beans – Assorted
$4.97 +View Product -
Handmade Chocolate Cherry Cups
$8.15 +View Product -
Handmade Chocolate Four-Flavor Stack
$9.45 +View Product -
Handmade Dark Chocolate Stack
$5.89 +View Product -
Handmade Milk Chocolate & Almonds Stack
$5.89 +View Product -
Handmade White Chocolate Stack
$5.89 +View Product -
Handmade Original Buttercrunch
$8.37 +View Product -
Handmade Milk Chocolate Stack
$5.89 +View Product -
Hard Candy Starlight Mints
$3.89 +View Product -
Heath Milk Chocolate English Toffee Candy Bar
$2.21 +View Product -
Retro Jawbreakers AKA Jaw Busters
$3.89 +View Product -
Jolly Ranchers
$3.89 +View Product -
JuJu Coins
$3.89 +View Product -
Junior Mints Theater Box
$2.21 +View Product -
Grapefruit-Ade
$13.47 +View Product -
Lemonade Stand in a Box
$21.00 +View Product -
Licorice Allsorts
$3.89 +View Product -
Licorice Bridge Mix with Pastels
$4.76 +View Product -
Red Licorice Laces
$4.76 +View Product -
Black Licorice Pipes
$1.21 +View Product -
LifeSavers – Pack of Three
$4.25 +View Product -
Sugar Charms
$3.89 +View Product -
Malted Milk Balls
$3.89 +View Product -
Vanilla Marshmallows
$5.25 +View Product -
Mary Janes
$3.89 +View Product -
Multi-Color Rock Candy Capsule
$12.25 +View Product -
Naked Sponge Candy AKA Sea Foam, Puff
$7.47 +View Product -
Napoleon Sours
$5.25 +View Product -
Wisconsin Raisins
$3.47 +View Product -
Nik L’ Nips
$2.21 +View Product -
Office Candy Chocolate
$5.25 +View Product -
Office Candy Classics
$5.25 +View Product -
Office Candy Soft & Chewy
$5.25 +View Product -
Handmade Original Peanut Butter Cups
$5.88 +View Product -
Peanut Chews
$2.21 +View Product -
Pearson’s Nut Roll
$2.21 +View Product -
Pixy Stix, Retro Fizz
$2.21 +View Product -
Pop Rocks – Retro Fun!
$1.36 +View Product -
Raspberry Filled Holiday Candy
$6.47 +View Product -
Red & White Jelly Hearts
$4.25 +View Product -
Retro Bourbon Caramels
$6.47 +View Product -
Ribbon Candy
$4.25 +View Product -
Swiss Chocolate
$12.25 +View Product -
Root Beer Barrels
$3.89 +View Product -
Sack O’ Coins
$3.89 +View Product -
Satellite Wafer (Flying Saucers)
$3.89 +View Product -
Skybar
$2.97 +View Product -
Soft Licorice Drops
$4.76 +View Product -
Sparkling Holiday Classics Mix – AKA Victory Mix!
$4.25 +View Product -
Sparkling Holiday Clear Toy (Barley Candy) Lollipops – Bag of 3
$4.25 +View Product -
Dutch Chalk Licorice
$4.76 +View Product -
Strawberry-Filled Candy
$5.47 +View Product -
Sugar Babies
$1.75 +View Product -
Sugar Daddy
$1.75 +View Product -
Swedish Fish
$3.89 +View Product -
Sweet As Sin – Signed by True Treats’ Founder & Candy Historian
$18.00 +View Product -
Teaberry Gum
$1.09 +View Product -
Timeless Truffles with Chocolate Filling
$14.97 +View Product -
Tootsie Roll Big Bar
$2.75 +View Product -
Hot Tamales
$3.89 +View Product -
Traditional Multicolored Gum Drops
$3.89 +View Product -
Pecan Divinity
$4.47 +View Product -
Truly Tart- Regal Crown Candy
$2.21 +View Product -
Turkish Taffy – Smack It, Crack It!
$1.49 +View Product -
Wax Lips
$1.96 +View Product -
Kentucky Bourbon Balls with Woodford Reserve
$12.25 +View Product -
Yesterday’s Medicine
$10.47 +View Product -
ZotZ
$3.89 +View Product