Showing 65–110 of 110 results
-
Traditional 1800s Jelly Beans
$3.47 View Product -
Hand Pulled Sticks- Sassafras
$5.25 View Product -
Hand-Pulled Sticks, circa 1600s – Peppermint
$5.25 View Product -
Handmade Chocolate Cherry Cups
$5.25 View Product -
Handmade Chocolate Four-Flavor Stack
$8.45 View Product -
Handmade Dark Chocolate Stack
$5.25 View Product -
Handmade Molasses Pulls, Traditional Candy
$4.25 View Product -
Handmade Milk Chocolate Stack
$5.25 View Product -
Horehound Drops
$3.47 View Product -
Pecan Pie Tarts
$3.47 View Product -
Retro Jawbreakers AKA Jaw Busters
$3.47 View Product -
Kentucky Creams
$5.25 View Product -
Kola Nut
$13.47 View Product -
Lemon Drops, Candy and Medicine for All
$4.25 View Product -
Lemonade Stand in a Box
$17.75 View Product -
Licorice Allsorts, British Candy
$3.47 View Product -
Malted Milk Balls, Favorite of Explorers
$3.47 View Product -
Vanilla Marshmallow Wonders
$5.25 View Product -
Molasses Drops
$4.25 View Product -
Original 1847 NECCO Wafers
$2.67 View Product -
Original Candy Cane – Hand-pulled. All natural. No stripe.
$6.47 View Product -
Original Sweetheart Candy in a Box
$0.97 View Product -
Peach Stones, Cherry Flavored Candy
$4.25 View Product -
Peanut Brittle, Rich 1800s Taste
$7.47 View Product -
Pecan Praline
$5.75 View Product -
Soft Pecan Pralines
$4.25 View Product -
Peppermint Puffs, Refreshing and Cool.
$3.47 View Product -
Peppermint Sticks – Parent to Candy Canes
$6.97 View Product -
Popcorn Balls
$1.21 View Product -
Reed’s Iconic Candies – Three Flavors
$2.21 View Product -
Rock Candy on a String, Multi-Purpose Tradition
$4.47 View Product -
Sorghum Drops
$4.25 View Product -
Sour Lime Drops
$4.25 View Product -
Dutch Chalk Licorice
$4.25 View Product -
Sweet As Sin – Signed by True Treats’ Founder
$18.00 View Product -
Take-A-Break Chocolate Covered Peanut Butter
$2.21 View Product -
Take-A-Break Chocolate Covered Raspberry
$2.21 View Product -
Take-A-Break Gummy Bears
$2.21 View Product -
Take-A-Break Mini Buckeyes
$2.21 View Product -
Take-A-Break Mini Nonpareils
$2.21 View Product -
Tootsie Roll Big Bar
$1.97 View Product -
Traditional Multicolored Gum Drops
$3.47 View Product -
Vanilla Sticks
$6.97 View Product -
Vassar Fudge
$7.25 View Product -
Vermont Maple Drops
$8.46 View Product -
Wilbur Buds, The Original Kiss
$4.25 View Product